I grew up in the Midwest—Wisconsin, to be exact.
And when most people think of Wisconsin, they think:

Cows.
Beer.
Cheese.
(And if you’re a sports fan… the Packers, obviously.)

But there’s another cultural staple that’s just as iconic, even if it isn’t on a postcard:

Midwest Nice.
Wisconsin Nice.
“Oh my gosh, everyone is just so… nice.”

Except… we all know “nice” is often a polite code phrase for something else:

👉 conflict avoidance wrapped in a warm dairy-scented blanket.

My son frequently reminds me that I’m not a Wisconsin native, which (according to him) explains why my version of “nice” doesn’t quite meet the local purity standards. And honestly? He’s probably right.

Because here’s the truth I’ve learned after decades in finance, logistics, operations, and leading teams:

---

⭐ The wrong kind of kindness is one of the biggest inefficiencies inside organizations.

Not true kindness.
Not empathy.
Not human decency.

The wrong kind of kindness is the kind that keeps people quiet.

The kind that leads to:

• Avoiding disagreements
• Softening feedback until it no longer means anything
• Agreeing publicly, disagreeing privately
• Saying “we’re fine” while quietly drowning
• Fixing other people’s mistakes to avoid an awkward conversation
• Smiling through processes that no longer work

This kind of “nice” feels good in the moment…
but it quietly tanks efficiency, accuracy, creativity, and team trust.

Because when niceness replaces honesty?
Teams don’t grow — they stall.

---

⭐ Here’s the twist: Honesty and kindness are NOT opposites.

In fact, the most kind thing you can do for your coworkers
is tell them the truth… respectfully, clearly, and early.

When I led finance teams, I encouraged open disagreement — even when (gulp) they didn’t agree with me.

And you know what happened?

We got smarter.
We got faster.
We uncovered gaps I hadn’t seen.
We created better solutions.
We trusted each other more.

No punishment for disagreement.
No defensiveness.
No tiptoeing.

Just adults doing great work with psychological safety.

That is kindness.
The real kind.

---

⭐ So let’s say it plainly: The wrong kind of “nice” is costing your company time and money.

The right kind of kindness — the honest, empathetic, respectful kind — creates:

✔ stronger processes
✔ faster problem-solving
✔ fewer repeated errors
✔ higher trust
✔ deeper team cohesion
✔ better ideas

Honesty isn’t harsh.
Harshness is harsh.
Honesty is clarity.

And clarity is efficient.

---

💥 BONUS: Honesty Is a Muscle — And Your Team Needs Reps

Now, before you panic:
No, I’m not suggesting we break out the “What’s your favorite color?” icebreakers.
Or the dreaded “If you were a tree, what kind would you be?” circle of awkwardness.

Hard pass.
Absolutely not.
Not under my leadership.

If you want real team alignment → you need real practice having honest conversations.
Respectful conversations.
Brave conversations that elevate the work instead of avoiding the moment.

So I created something you can actually use:

---

👉 FREE DOWNLOAD: The “Honesty & Empathy Reset Workshop”

A quick, simple, non-cringy team exercise you can run in 20 minutes.

No trust falls.
No kumbaya.
No crayons.
Just practical reps for the honesty muscles your team actually needs.

You can download it here:
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/all2sconsultingllc

Build a team culture where honesty is normal.
Where empathy is active.
Where “nice” doesn’t get in the way of progress.
Where people tell the truth early — and respectfully.

Because that’s the kind of kindness that drives real efficiency.